How to Fix Polyshades

You’re not alone if you’ve ever used Polyshades and been anything less than thrilled with the results. Unfortunately, many people have trouble getting the product to look right, no matter how hard they try. But don’t worry – there’s a fix. In this article, we’ll walk you through the steps on how to fix polyshades so that your project turns out looking great. Read on to learn more!

Polyshades are an excellent product for staining wood projects a darker color. The problem is that they don’t work as advertised on all types of wood. Because of this, many people try to fix polyshades with some magic formula or secret ingredient. Unfortunately, this doesn’t solve the problem, and you’re still left with a project that isn’t what you’d hoped for. But there’s a straightforward solution to fixing polyshades that won’t cost you any money at all!

Summary: Polyshades are a problem because they are hard to see. You can’t see through them, so it’s hard to tell what is on the other side. You can’t see what is behind them. To fix polyshades, you need to make them transparent. You can use a window or a door as a guide. Then, you can paint the outside of the polyshades with a light color. This will make the polyshades more visible.

How to Fix Polyshades

Tools and Materials

  1. Q-tips
  2. Polyshades Stain (Dark Walnut)
  3. Wood Glue (Elmer’s White Glue Stick)
  4. Clothes Iron
  5. Bowl of Ice Water
  6. Scraper or Cardboard Scraper Tool
  7. Fabric, Styrofoam
  8. Brush, pencil, or stick with wax on end (for mixing)
  9. Quart mason jar
  10. Water (tap), 1 cup distilled water + 4 tablespoons salt (required for removing creme colorant stains). It also works without salt.

A Stepwise Guide on How to Fix Polyshades

Step 1: Determine How Much Creme Colorant Stain Remover to Mix

Polyshades bottles do not indicate how much creme colorant should be mixed for a quart of stain. However, we can be sure that if it’s not enough, the color will come out too light, and we’ll have wasted our time and money trying to fix this product. On the other hand, we should mix up plenty because the salt solution will evaporate and eventually need more water added.

Mix Salt and More Water

We can solve both issues by mixing up as much as possible at one time then storing the extra in a mason jar with a small amount of remaining colorant solvent. Let’s start with 1 cup of tap water + 4 tablespoons of salt (the maximum quantity you can add to a quart of water before it will no longer dissolve.) This should be especially effective since the colorant solvent is much more soluble in this mixture than in plain tap water.

Step 2: Mixing and Stirring the Creme Colorant

Make a mark on the mason jar at the 1 cup of the tap water line (you’ll need to mix up more of this solution soon).

Pour about half of the bottle of Polyshades into your measuring cup. How much? Well, if you’re like me and don’t want to continue using expensive wood stains that give such lousy results, then you’re going to be using all of it; but if you’re going to get rid of the white spots that

Get Rid of the White Spots

formed, then you can use less since we still have plenty of color solvent in the bottle.

Add 1/4th cup distilled water into the measuring cup with Polyshades to mix more evenly. Stir thoroughly with a stick or pencil, making sure to break up any chunks of pigment formed in the colorant solvent. Do not get sharpened pencils or sticks wet if you use a Q-tip for this step! They will become fragile and might break during mixing.

Make another mark on the mason jar at about 1/2 cup of distilled water + Polyshades solution (or roughly 1/4th of the measuring cup depending on how much colorant solvent you’re using). This is probably close enough since we will mix more before putting it into the mason jar anyway.

Pour the contents of the measuring cup into the mason jar. Repeat with distilled water, Polyshades colorant solvent, and salt solution four times (or until you’ve used up all of your creme colorant stain removers.) Use a funnel to make the process easier.

  1. Close the mason jar and shake it up until everything is mixed together.
  2. Invert your jar, allowing the creme colorant remover solution to flow down into the bowl. This can get a little messy so be sure to put something under your work area to catch any drips
  3. Continue inverting the jar until no more liquid flows out of the opening. If you have any remaining creme colorant solution in the jar, pour it into the bowl as well.

Step 3: Mixing the Water-Based Wood Glue Solution

I’ll be mixing up about four batches of this solution since I’m very picky about getting rid of white spots on my floors where I used Polyshades Dark Walnut, but most people will probably only need to do two or three batches, so they don’t waste as much wood glue.

Let the jar of white glue sit out for 5-10 minutes to be easier to mix. I mixed up 1 cup of Elmer’s White Glue + 4 tablespoons salt just like with the Polyshades colorant solvent, but if you’re using a different brand, you’ll have to experiment.

Pour Some White Glue Solutions

Pour some white glue solutions into your mason jar and stir well with a Popsicle stick or pencil (again, don’t get them wet) until it is thoroughly mixed (about 15 seconds). Now, add more solution until the gel has turned into a watery liquid (roughly another 1/4th cup, depending on how much you started with). Let’s say I only used about half of it.

This project is about making a stained glass jar. You will need three jars/containers. One jar will have a salt solution and water-based glue mixture. This will be used to rinse off the white spots. The other two jars will contain creme colorant solvent and water. One jar will be marked at 1 cup + Polyshades colorant solvent and the other jar will be marked at one-quarter cup.

Step 4: Rinsing off White Spots on Wood Floor

Before starting this step, make sure that your mop is clean from all dust particles, hair, etc. You don’t want anything in your finished product or else your wood floor will come out looking like a mess! If you’re like me, then your mop probably won’t be clean at this point since I had to resort to these colorant solvent removers after giving up on Birchwood Casey.

If you used the applicator brush to apply Polyshades to your floor, you may have noticed that there were no white spots or streaks. However, if you continued with the rest of the process, white spots would have formed on your wood flooring.

This is why we will use our water-based glue solution mixed with salt + creme colorant solvent remover. Grab a mop and start rinsing with room temperature water. How much depends on how many batches of solution you mixed up, but I usually do about half the mop at a time.

Once you are done rinsing it off, make sure to dry your floor with paper towels, or else it will be tough to clean! If you have any stubborn white spots that don’t want to go away, use your Popsicle stick or pencil (again, don’t get wet) to massage the area until it is gone. It takes some patience, but trust me–it works! I’ve seen this method work several times before, so I’m confident it’ll work for you.

Step 5: Cleaning up and Make Sure it Never Happens Again!

To clean your floor properly, you need to not only fix the white spots, but also wipe down the entire floor to make sure it is dry. If you don’t do this, your floor can become very slippery when it rains.

Also, I like to clean up the Polyshades applicator brush with dish soap because I found that there were still Polyshades between the bristles even though I rinsed off the excess seen in the photo above. After stirring it up for about fifteen seconds with my pencil (which I didn’t bother washing), it had turned into an orangey-brown color which indicates that not all of it had been released into the jar–thus creating white spots.

Creating White Spots

I’m sure this would have happened if I had cleaned it with water only, but the dish soap worked perfectly! All of that Polyshades was immediately released into the mixture in my mason jar, and I cleaned out the brush without any problems. These steps will help in how to fix polyshades.

This method may sound very complicated, but I assure you that it is much easier than you think! Of course, the most complex process is making all of your colorant solvent solutions because they are all mixed at different concentrations–so make sure to measure each one thoroughly before mixing, or else you’ll end up with a big mess to clean up.

This person tried using a different method for painting, and it worked out better than they expected.

You Can Check It Out To Fix Wrinkled Paint

Tips and Warnings

  • Avoid sanding, if possible. However, suppose you must sand lightly by hand with fine sandpaper (220 grit). Sanding may create unwanted brush marks due to the thicker viscosity of Polyshades.
  • Stains may be added before or after the first coat of Polyshades; however, stains applied on top of the finish will show scratches on the polyurethane coat beneath it.
  • Clean your brushes immediately after use with water and mild soap or Brush Soap for best results. Do not leave flat paint brushes standing in water as this causes bristle deformation and loss of absorbency resulting in poor performance. Nylon round tips are more durable and will not require cleaning after use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do You Wipe Off Excess Polyshades?

If you are using a poly shade garment to cover your head or face, it is important to remember that you should always wipe off any excess sweat and sunscreen before putting on your shaded outfit. This will avoid the buildup of these substances on the fabric and potentially lead to skin irritation or worse. Additionally, if there is rain in the forecast for the evening hours, be sure to remove your poly shades prior to going outside so that they do not get wet and ruined.

Can You Poly Over Polyshades?

Depends on a variety of factors, including the type of Polyshades you are using and your hair texture. However, a few general tips that may help include using heat on your Polyshades before applying them, combing your hair back before applying the Polyshades, and leaving the Polyshades on for a shorter period of time than usual. Good luck and we hope this information helps!

What Happens if I Don’t Sand Between Coats of Polyurethane?

Poorly sanded finishes can result in a number of problems, including water infiltration, growth of mold and mildew, warping wood, and even damage to the finish. By using appropriate sandpaper for your particular coating system, you can avoid these issues.

If you are unsure about which sandpaper is right for your project, it’s best to consult with a professional coatings contractor or drywall finisher. They will be able to guide you through the proper step-by-step procedure for achieving a properly Sanded Finish.

Is Polyshades Oil or Water Based?

Polyshades is water-based oil paint and the two products are not interchangeable. Polyshades Oil has a thicker consistency while Polyshades Water is thinner and more transparent.

Do You Smooth Out Polyshades?

The best approach may vary depending on your hair type and texture. However, generally speaking, it is advisable to smooth out poly shades every time you apply them in order to avoid any frizz or flyaways. This can be done by using a serum or conditioner before applying the shaders and combing through them until they are fully absorbed into the hair follicle.


We hope you have learned how to fix polyshades. Polyshades can be a great way to add color and depth to your home, but sometimes they don’t turn out exactly as you planned. If that’s the case for you, don’t worry – we have a few tips to help you fix Polyshades. Follow these simple steps, and before you know it, your botched Polyshade job will be looking like new.

You Can Check It Out To How to Fix Wrinkled Paint

Leave a Comment